Intelligentguess

Analysis of Market Economics

April 30th, 2007

RBI hikes MSS - Eases pressure on SLR

The Reserve Bank of India has, over the weekend, hiked the limit for issuance government bonds under the market stabilization scheme (MSS) to INR 1.1 trln. This is up from the previous limit of INR 950 bn. Even the 950 bn limit was an increase from the previous cap of 850 bn and set as recently as Apr 25.

MSS is the mechanism by which the Indian central bank has been sterilizing the (excess) liquidity in the monetary system on an enduring basis. Ironically, the central bank itself is responsible for most of the liquidity generation due to its active intervention in the forex markets. RBI has, under its exchange rate policy, effectively prevented the Indian rupee from appreciating much. This has been done through a process of active intervention in the currency markets through large scale purchases of foreign currency, most of which is an outcome of increased capital foreign capital inflows into the country.

The increase in the MSS limit has been necessisated due to the limited headroom available with RBI on its sterilization efforts. INR 780 bn of MSS issuance is already outstanding. This means that the headroom now available on this account is now INR 370 bn. Since some of the MSS issuance is in the form of treasury bills which mature periodically. These are mostly perpetuated through a refinancing mechanism of issuing fresh bills. Thus, assuming that on an average the central bank issues Rs. 30 bn of longer dated bonds under the MSS mechanism, it has approximately 3 months time till it hits the cap. This is clearly too short a time period for the comfort of the central bank. I’m sure that Mr. Reddy, the governor is wishing for a slowdown in inflows to enable him manage this monetisation better. My feeling is that if it comes to it, he would not hesitate in hiking the cash reserve ratio itself to aid the sterilization efforts.

In the meantime, the Indian currency has appreciated sharply (approximately 10% in 2 months). It has been aided in this move, by a somewhat hands off approach adopted by the RBI. A subtle shift in its exchange rate policy has become noticeable. It no longer seems to be finicky about preventing the rupee from appreciating. Mr. Reddy has also spoken, in some recent media interviews, about the exchange rate policy to be viewed in the larger context of public policy (whatever that statement means).

There is one other reason why the MSS limit would have needed to be hiked. To relieve pressure on the central bank to reduce the statutory liquidity ratio (SLR), the proportion of deposits that a bank has to compulsorily invest in government bonds. This ratio is currently pegged at 25%.

Bank deposits are expected to grow by INR 5 trn this financial year. To meet the 25% norm, banks would have to buy INR 1.25 trn in government bonds. Fresh issuance by the government is budgeted at INR 1.1 trn. Assuming that a significant proportion of the fresh issuance is absorbed by non banks (primarily insurance companies and provident funds), banks would have been left scrambling to meet the SLR requirement, unless it was reduced. By hiking the MSS issuance limit, the central bank has eased the pressure on this front a wee bit.

Clearly, interesting times lie ahead.

April 24th, 2007

Indian Monetary Policy - Quick Comments

The RBI has released the Governor, Mr. Y V Reddy’s statement on the quarterly review of the monetary policy today. Given below is the note that i wrote to clients immediately after the policy announcement reproduced verbatim

Policy Stance

The monetary policy stance of the central bank strives

  • To reinforce the emphasis on price stability and well-anchored inflation expectations while ensuring monetary and interest rate environment that supports export and investment demand in the economy so as to enable continuation of the growth momentum.
  • To re-emphasise credit quality and orderly conditions in financial markets for securing macroeconomic and, in particular, financial stability while simultaneously pursuing greater credit penetration and financial inclusion.
  • To respond swiftly with all possible measures as appropriate to the evolving global and domestic situation impinging on inflation expectations and the growth momentum.

This statement of the monetary policy stance is identical to the statement of the January policy review.

Policy Action & Monetary Measures

In line with the policy stance, the following monetary measures have been taken

  • No change in the bank rate which is currently 6%. No change in CRR, which remains at 6.5%.
  • No change in the daily reverse repo rate, the rate at which banks lend to RBI, which has been kept unchanged at 6%.
  • No change in the daily repo rate, the rate at which banks lend to RBI, which has been kept unchanged at 7.75%.

In addition, the estimate for GDP growth for the current fiscal has been revised to around 8.5% from the earlier 8.5%-9.0% projected in the. Significantly the inflation target of 5% - 5.5% has been replaced with a target of 4%-4.5%.

Comments

The central bank has released a policy statement that seems to be more benign than the statement accompanying the previous policy review in January.

Significantly, the Governor has opted for no change in the policy rates and the cash reserve ratio.

This is mildly bullish for the bond markets as some market participants had expected a hike in at least one of the policy rates.

More important elements of the policy statement figure elsewhere. Of special import is the central bank’s view on the tolerance level for inflation. Significantly, the downward revision in the inflation target seems to suggest reduced tolerance to inflation.

Among other steps announced by the RBI, many are targeted towards easing conditions for money flow out of the country. This is clearly intended to counter the large capital inflows that we have been witnessing. The facilitation of outflows is intended to counter the large forex inflows being witnessed. Measures announced include

  • Overseas investment limit (total financial commitments) for Indian companies enhanced to 300 per cent of their net worth.
  • Listed Indian companies limit for portfolio investment abroad in listed overseas companies enhanced to 35 per cent of net worth.
  • Aggregate ceiling on overseas investment by mutual funds enhanced to US $ 4 billion.
  • Prepayment of external commercial borrowings (ECBs) without prior Reseve Bank approval increased to US $ 400 million.
  • Present limit for individuals for any permitted current or capital account transaction increased from US $ 50,000 to US $ 100,000 per financial year in the liberalised remittance scheme.
  • Ceiling interest rate on FCNR(B) and NR(E)RA deposits reduced by 50 basis points

Amongst other significant announcements, the permission to banks and primary dealers to trade in single entity credit default swaps is a welcome step. Hopefully, this should bring some life to the hitherto moribund corporate bond market.

Setting up of a working group on currency futures is also a step in the right direction. We hope the working group would complete its assignment in double quick time to enable the introduction of this instrument in the domestic markets with alacrity.

Similarly a working group has also been proposed to be set up to work on the interest rate futures market which has failed to take off ostensibly due to deficiencies in product design and certain policy restrictions.

Risk weights on residential housing loans to individuals for loans upto INR 2 mn has been reduced temporarily to 50%. This move seems to have been taken under guidance from the finance ministry.

The interest rate ceiling on NBFC deposits has been raised by 150 basis points to 12.5% p.a. This is in line with the enhanced interest rates on comparable investments.

Finally, the no rate hike seen today means that the chances of a rate hike in the next policy review seem enhanced. This is especially so since the tolerance levels on inflation are now reduced to a great extent.

April 24th, 2007

India - Monetary Policy Statement released

The Reserve Bank of India released its annual monetary policy statement a few minutes ago.

The press release is here. The full text of the statement is here.

The key decision has been to keep all policy rates unchanged.

I shall give detailed views on the policy in a separate post.

April 23rd, 2007

UK - Inflation ( CPI) at its highest since Sept’92

 

Situation

On a monthly basis prices rose by 0.48 % (0.48% in Feb’07)

On an annual basis prices rose by  3.07 p.a ( 2.78% p.a in Feb’07)

 

Background

  • Bank of England ( BOE) has an inflation target ( CPI ) of 2% p.a.
  • BOE’s current policy rate is at 5.25% p.a .The Bank Rate was raised by 0.25% to 5.25% in Jan’07
  • Producer prices have had a sharp rise in Mar’07 
  • Crude prices which were averaging 59.38$  in Feb’07 had risen to a 60.73 $ average in Mar’07 ( 2.26% rise)
  • As on Apr 22 ‘07 crude is averaging at 63.39$. ( 4.39% more than Mar’07) 

 

Conclusion

 

  • Crude prices has not dropped as yet and instead the average has risen in Apr’07.
  • The effects of the Jan’07 rate hike would start taking effect in April 2007 ( which at the same time may get negated by the rise in crude )
  • As such inflation may remain in April at the 3.00% area prior to dropping towards the 2.50% p.a area in mid’07.

     

  •  

    In relationship to the monetary policy meeting on May 10th 2007

    1. The behavior of the Pound viz other currencies suggests that the market is expecting a rate hike

    On the other hand

    1. Production has declined in Q1 2007  (data upto Feb’07).
    2. GDP growth remained flat in Q4 2006 ( and in relationship to production declines , is not expected to rise in Q1 2007)
    3. A raise of interest rates will bring down demand / inflation pressures ( but at the same time drive growth even lower from Q2 2007 onwards) . 

    Tis’ a fine balancing act for the BOE 

     

     

    Related Links

     

     

    April 23rd, 2007

    Monetary Policy - What will Reddy do?

    RBI Logo

    India’s central bank, RBI, releases its annual monetary policy statement Tuesday, April 24 at 0630 hrs UTC.Y V Reddy

    Analysts widely expect Y V Reddy (YVR), the RBI Governor to continue his hawkish tone in the language of the statement.

    There are differences, however, amongst them on whether the central bak would actually go ahead with a rate hike and/or increase in the statutory pre emption of funds (hike in the cash reserve ratio).

    The measures announced on March 30 are yet to take effect in full. The second phase of the increased CRR kicks in only this weekend. This, seems to be the main reason why analysts do not expect an immediate announcement of a rate hike.

    Personally, I think that a further increase in the cash reserve ratio may be deferred, YVR is unlikely to stay put on the benchmark rate. A 0.25% hike in the official “repo” rate (the rate at which RBi lends to banks) seems more likely. This would take the repo rate to 8%. The reverse repo rate (the rate at which RBi borrows from banks) is at 6%.

    A 25 bps hike in the repo rate would take the spread between the official repo and reverse repo rates to 2%. If we remember, the spread between these rates at the time they were fixed initially had been 2%. Successive reductions had brought the spread down to 1%. YVR has, consciously, since October 2006 steadily increased the spread in successive monetary policy announcements. It appears that the game plan is to take this spread back to the originally conceived 2%.

    Further hikes in benchmark rates in future might involve an increase in both the “repo” rate as well as the “reverse repo” rate.

    April 22nd, 2007

    USA - Production grows in Mar’07 at the slowest pace since Sept’05

    Situation

    On a monthly basis

    Production ( IIP) dropped by -0.2 % in Mar’07 ( 0.8% in Feb’07) .

    On an annual basis 

    Production grew by 2.3% p.a in Mar’07 ( 3.0% p.a in Feb’07).

    The rate of capacity utilization fell 0.2 % to 81.4 %( was 81.6% in Feb’07). The average capacity utilization between 1972 - 2006 is 81% .

    Background

    1. Production had grown at 3.0% in Feb’07 ( restated from 3.4% )
    2. New orders continued its declines in Feb’07 ( effects Mar’07 and Apr’07 production). 
    3. Orders  do not look like it will improve dramatically. i.e may not drop heavily - but rises may not be strong either. ( see: New orders )

    Conclusion  (click on image for a bigger visual)

    • Production looks like retaining a range between 2.10% p.a ( initially) towards a top of 4.00% p.a until mid ‘07
    • If slowdown in orders continues ( due to the current inventory ) it would result in production growth down towards the sub 0% towards a -5.00% towards end’07

    Recently the fed has talked about a possibility of considering rate increases. This may not be possible unless there is some growth in inventory offtake ( thereby creating a possibility of mismatch  between demand and supply resulting in inflation)

    Related Links

    1. USA - Production grows by 3.4 percent per annum in Feb’07 (2.7 percent in Jan’07)
    2. USA - New Orders continues declines in Feb’07 ( annual basis)
    1. Euro area - Production (IIP) grows in Feb’07
    2. India - Production continues to drop in Feb’07 
    3. UK - Production: Sluggish growth in Feb’07
    4. Japan : IIP - Production grows moderately in Feb’07 (on an annual basis)
    April 20th, 2007

    Indian inflation remains high - Expect hawkish monetary policy to continue

    India released its provisional weekly inflation data today.

    Headline inflation based on yoy change in  the Wholesale Price Index (WPI) came in at 6.08% for the week ended April 7. This is in contrast to the figure of 5.74% reported a week earlier. Analysts had forecast a figure of 5.80% for the current release. The actual number is therefore about 25-30 basis points above forecast. The index itself rose 0.4% week on week to 210.8 from 210.0.

    This is the last inflation release before the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) releases its monetary policy statement on April 24.

    I expect no change in the increasingly hawkish stance that the RBI has been taking in conduct of its monetary policy.

    April 19th, 2007

    USA - Inflation (CPI) inches up in Mar’07 , while core inflation drops

     

    Situation

     

    On a monthly basis

    • Prices rose by 0.91% (0.54% in Feb’07)
    • Core inflation ( inflation excluding volatile items) growth dropped to by 0.39% (0.53% in Feb’07) 

    On an annual basis

    • Prices rose by  2.78% p.a ( 2.42% p.a in Feb’07)
    • Core inflation ( inflation excluding volatile items) growth dropped to 2.5% p.a (2.7% p.a in Feb’07) 

     

    Background

    • Core CPI has dropped. (click on image for a larger visual )
    • Producer prices are at its highest levels in the past 6 months ( 3.21% p.a)Crude prices which were averaging 59.38$  in Feb’07 had risen to a 60.73 $ average in Mar’07 ( 2.26% rise)
    • As on April 16 ‘07 crude is averaging at 63.58$. ( 4.7% more than Mar’07) 

     

     

    Conclusion ( click on image for a larger visual)

    1. CPI looks likely to retain the 3 % p.a - 1.3% p.a range till mid ‘07. ( drops due post Apr’07)
    2. The minutes of the last monetary policy meeting offers an interesting direction - as to the future monetary policy of the Fed.
    3. Read the note

     

     

    Note

    Point 1

    Have a look at the manner in which the UK Producer prices behaved upto Mar’07 ( see  : UK Producer prices Mar’07) and compare the visual to the Producer price behaviour in the US.

    Its the same

    However in this scenario - the media states that UK may consider a interest rate hike - while at the same time US would consider an interest rate drop.

    Just looking at the image - the picture for Producer prices - states that the US and UK are in the same situation.

     

    Point II

    Have a look at the manner in which the Euro Consumer behaved upto Mar’07 ( see  : Euro Consumer Mar’07) and compare the visual to the Consumer price behaviour in the US.

    Its the same

    However in this scenario - the ECB states that they may consider a interest rate hike - while at the same time the media states that US would consider an interest rate drop.

    Just looking at the image - the picture for Consumer prices - states that the US and Europe are in the same situation.

     

    Related links

    April 17th, 2007

    Euro area - Inflation (CPI) flat in Mar’07

    Situation

    On a monthly basis

    • Prices rose by 0.67% (0.29% in Feb’07)
    • Core inflation ( inflation excluding volatile items) grew by 0.72% (0.39% in Feb’07) 

    On an annual basis

    • Prices rose by  1.94% p.a ( 1.84% p.a in Feb’07)
    • Core inflation ( inflation excluding volatile items) grew by 1.87% p.a (same as in Feb’07) 

    Background

    1. Producer prices have been on a decline since Jun’06  ( 2.92% currently)
    2. The European Commercial bank ( ECB) aims at inflation ( CPI ) rates of below, but close to, 2% over the medium term. They have achieved this primary goal ( Note : inspite of inflation being at below 2% p.a since Sept’06 the ECB did raise interest rates by 0.25% in Mar’09)
    3. Crude prices which were averaging 59.38$  in Feb’07 had risen to a 60.73 $ average in Mar’07 ( 2.26% rise)
    4. As on April 16 ‘07 crude is averaging at 63.58$. ( 4.7% more than Mar’07) 

    Conclusion

    • The decline in producer prices may keep the inflation ( CPI) between  1.5% p.a - 2.00% p.a in the coming months.
    • As such rise in interest rates would not normally be expected

    HOWEVER :

    1. European Central Bank council member Guy Quaden said the bank is “likely” to raise interest rates again to counter inflation in the 13 nations sharing the euro.
    2. ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet last week endorsed investors’ expectations that the bank will raise borrowing costs again in Jun’07

    Related links

    April 17th, 2007

    UK - Producer prices ( PPI) have a sharp rise in Mar’07

    Situation

    On a monthly basis

    • PPI rose by 0.6% ( 0.4%,revised, in Feb’07)
    • Core PPI rose 0.5% ( same level as in Feb’07)

    On an annual basis

    • PPI rose by 2.68% p.a ( 2.31% p.a ,revised, in Feb’07)
    • Core PPI rose by 2.92% p.a ( 2.74% p.a,revised, in Feb’07)

    Background

    1. Bank of England ( BOE) has an inflation target ( CPI ) of 2% p.a.
    2. Current CPI in Feb’07 is at 2.78% p.a ( been dropping since Dec’06 from 2.97% p.a)
    3. The Bank of Englands current policy rate is at 5.25% p.a
    4. PPI was dropping from Jun’06 ( 3.39% p.a) and was its lowest in Oct’06 (1.58 % p.a)
    5. Crude prices which were averaging 59.38$  in Feb’07 had risen to a 60.73 $ average in Mar’07 ( 2.26% rise)
    6. As on April 16 ‘07 crude is averaging at 63.58$. ( 4.7% more than Mar’07) 

    Conclusion ( see image for a larger visual)

    • Crude prices has not dropped as yet and instead the average has risen in Apr’07.
    • PPI looks likely to retain a range of 2.90% ( on upside) and 2% until mid’07. ( previously the range was expected to be 2.5% on upside, since the 2.26% rise in crude was not taken into account )  
    • CPI prices may continue to retain a 2.70% p.a - 3.00% p.a on the fall of PPI from Jun’06 to Dec’06 ( lead effect) - and the effect of crude prices rise
    • As such the BOE may continue to defer any interest rate considerations ( unless CPI has a sharp rise)

    Related links

    Close
    E-mail It